[Table of Contents] [Feb 2009]
[Nov
2008] [Aug 2008]
[May
2008]
[Feb 2008]
[Nov
2007] [Aug 2007]
[May
2007] [Feb 2007]
[Nov
2006]
[Aug 2006]
[May
2006] [Feb 2006]
[Nov
2005]
BLOOD ROYAL
Vanora Bennett, HarperCollins, 2009,
£12.99, hb, 592pp, 9780007281930
This first in a series is the story of Catherine
de Valois, daughter of Charles, King of France. Brought up with her
younger brother Charles at the French court, dominated by the
temperamental Queen Isabeau, Catherine’s childhood is one of deprivation
rather than luxury. Her only friend is the poet and advisor of kings,
Christine de Pizan. Catherine longs to escape the intrigues of the French
court and does this through her marriage to Henry V of England. Although
this is a political marriage, Catherine appears to fall in love with her
kingly husband. It is only after his death that all the skills she learnt,
from dealing with the insanity of her own father, Charles, and her
trouble-making mother, are used in trying to protect Harry, her son, from
the political aspirations of Duke Humphrey and the war-hardened Warwick.
Henry’s death also provides the opportunity for Catherine to renew her
youthful friendship with Owain Tudor, a dispossessed young Welshman.
Owain’s understanding and loyalty to both Harry and Catherine enable her
to find the peace and love that has always eluded
her.
This novel is a skilful blend of fact and
fiction. Weaving together all the historically important figures of the
time such as Christine de Pizan, Jehanne, who is burnt for heresy, and
Cardinal Beaufort, it provides the reader with a glimpse of the hardships
of life, even in courtly circles, during a period of war between England
and France. Personally, this period is not historically one of my
favourites, but Vanora Bennett’s novel has made me think again. Her
characters, story, and fluid writing style sweep you along in a pageant of
medieval life. This is quite simply an excellent read! --
Myfanwy Cook
THE RED VELVET
TURNSHOE
Cassandra Clark, John Murray, 2009, £18.99, hb, 272pp,
9781848540293
In February of the year 1383 a
rain started to fall before Martinmas. It swept through France, Flanders,
and Tuscany causing floods and famine. Europe is dangerous. There is
plague and the Hundred Years War is causing political turmoil. Hildegard,
the nun heroine of Hangman Blind, is sent on a dangerous mission to
bring the Cross of Constantine from Italy to York. A disappearance, a
murder, and a grisly discovery in Bruges set in action a terrifying course
of events for Hildegard. She leaves Bruges accompanied by the young,
arrogant musician Pierrekyn, murder suspect, and Talbot, her knight
protector. They arrive at the monastery on St. Bernard’s Pass during a
snowstorm, and by now the novel’s events are spiraling. For the next
two-thirds of this story, the reader is gripped by suspense, the
revelation of characters noble and bad, and a deep political secret that
endangers King Richard’s crown. Many want Hildegard’s mission to fail, and
one character plans a deadly revenge.
The story is
ingenious, the plotting is suspenseful, the characters are portrayed with
depth and subtlety, the writing is atmospheric. Cassandra Clark’s novel is
literary, detailed, and thoroughly researched, making it a delicious read
for any lover of historical writers such as C. J. Sansom or Philippa
Gregory, with the added advantage of an original, brilliantly portrayed
and unforgettable heroine. -- Carol
McGrath
THE GLASS OF
TIME
Michael Cox, Norton, 2008, $24.95, hb,
586pp, 9780393067736 / John Murray, 2008, £17.99, hb, 544pp,
9780719597206
Esperanza Gorst is an orphan,
raised in Paris by her guardian, the mysterious Madame de l’Orme. When she
is in her teens, Esperanza’s guardian places her in the home of Emily,
Lady Tansor, as a lady’s maid, and insists that Esperanza find a way into
Lady Tansor’s confidence. Though Esperanza is unsure why, Madame de l’Orme
promises to reveal the truth of the escapade through three letters, which
she will send periodically. As Esperanza receives the letters and begins
to learn the truth about her parentage and her relationship with Lady
Tansor, she finds there are numerous questions waiting to be answered—and
that she isn’t who she believed she was.
This i
s a ghost story without ghosts, a tale of family
secrets revealed, past cruelties avenged, and a young
woman who finds herself coming of age in a way she could never have
expected. The epic, neo-Victorian narrative style, reminiscent of classic
works of 19th-century literature, made me feel as if I were
peeping through a keyhole and sneaking glances at a secret diary as the
story unraveled. It helps to have read Cox’s first novel, The Meaning
of Night, before beginning The Glass of Time, since the stories
are intertwined, and questions left lingering at the
end of the earlier book are resolved. All in all, a fantastic,
extraordinarily detailed world to lose yourself in, and an essential read.
-- Nanette Donohue
THE GREAT LOVER
Jill Dawson,
Sceptre, 2009, £12.99, hb, 310pp, 9780340935651
The island of Tahiti
holds a fascination for troubled souls. Gauguin lived there in the 1890s.
So too, in the early months of 1914, did poet Rupert Brooke, the subject
of this vivid novel. He died in the east Mediterranean the following year
of septicaemia, at the age of twenty-seven. Author Jill Dawson has delved
into the darkness of his life, at odds with the romantic, lyrical poet of
popular imagination.
The book begins in 1982 with a
letter from Arlice Rapoto, Brooke’s daughter in Tahiti. The recipient is
ninety-year-old Nell Golightly, formerly maid at the Orchard Tea Gardens,
Grantchester, where Brooke stayed before WW1. Arlice wants to know about
the famous father she never met: how he smelled and sounded, what it felt
like to ‘wrap arms around him’. The main part of the novel takes us back
to 1909, the story of Brooke and Nell—an intelligent, practical girl who
keeps bees—up to 1914, told in alternating first-person
narrative.
The fictional Nell, inspired by a
postcard the author bought when visiting the Orchard House, is a brilliant
creation. She is attracted to Brooke, struck by his beauty. He is a
seamless fusion of his poetry, letters, travel writings, essays,
photographs, and the author’s imagination. He is confused about his
sexuality, worried about his sanity and his ‘burdensome virginity’, which
he eventually loses to a school friend. He has lots of visitors: Lytton
Strachey, Virginia Stephen (Woolf), and other literati. The constraints of
social position ensure his relationship with Nell develops at a distance:
much observation, musing—she becomes in his imagination ‘a sumptuous nymph
… unearthly creature— bolstered by snatched conversations and a naked
bathe in Byron’s Pool.'
A touching, engrossing story
of a love affair and of a damaged man unable to allow others to reach him.
-- Janet Hancock
PALACE
CIRCLE
Rebecca Dean, Broadway, 2009, $14.00,
pb, 415pp, 9780767930550 / Harper, 2009, £6.99, pb, 608pp,
9780007268436
It’s been a long time since I was
as caught up in a novel as I was in Palace Circle. The action
sweeps from London’s glittering debutante balls to the crowded streets of
World War II Cairo, with seamless transitions between scenes and
viewpoints and never a dull moment throughout. In 1911, eighteen-year-old
Delia Chandler marries Viscount Ivor Conisborough, twenty-two years her
elder, exchanging carefree days at her beloved Virginia home for a life of
privilege at the Windsor court. She adjusts quickly, captivating
aristocrats and politicians alike with her Southern charm and outgoing
personality. Despite the casual acceptance of love affairs among members
of her circle, Delia believes her marriage to be an exception to the
rule—until she comes face to face with Ivor’s gorgeous long-time
mistress.
After the births of
her children, Delia finds happiness in her own extramarital liaison until
her husband’s posting to Cairo separates her from her lover. Ivor’s role
as advisor to King Fuad and tutor to his son, Prince Farouk, becomes
critical to British interests as Egyptian revolutionaries gain ground and
the Nazis rise in power. The two Conisborough
daughters, Petra and Davina, grow up in an ethnically diverse prewar Egypt
but pursue different paths in life. Their romantic entanglements are
complicated by their father’s politics and secrets from their mother’s
past.
Dean writes with a light touch that
reflects the freewheeling spirit of the era; notables like Margot Asquith,
Wallis Simpson, and Winston Churchill breeze through the narrative as they
briefly interact with the fictional characters. Although the pacing is
brisk, Dean doesn’t neglect the smaller details that add so much vibrancy
to her settings. In all, Palace Circle is a saga both
intellectually lively and emotionally satisfying. Its four hundred-plus
pages passed by much too quickly; I wouldn’t have minded four hundred
more. -- Sarah Johnson
WILD ORCHID
Cameron Dokey, Simon & Schuster, 2009, $6.99,
pb, 200pp, 9781416971689
In this retelling of “The Ballad
of Mulan” for the young adult reader, told in the first person, Cameron
Dokey breathes fresh life into an archetypal story of a cross-dressing
young woman who goes to war in defense of her beloved China and in place
of her father. We are quickly won to the side of its heroine, who came
into the world as the blossom of an unconventional love match. Her
grief-stricken father does not come home to meet her until Mulan is a
teenager, and he’s forced into retirement by war injuries and an angry
emperor. He discovers a daughter who loves climbing trees and learning
forbidden skills from her friend, Li Po. Father and daughter struggle
through their new relationship, but soon a new, very feminine wife joins
the household. She becomes pregnant just as the Huns advance again on
China and the Emperor sends out his call. Mulan takes up her father’s
armor and warhorse and joins Li Po’s archers. Her skills bring her to the
attention of the emperor’s youngest son, and she joins him in a daring
attempt to turn the tide of the invasion.
Elegant in
its simplicity, Wild Orchid is also deep in its exploration of
conventions associated with culture—from expected obedience of children,
to the power of a mother-in-law, to gender and class divisions. The
novel’s heroine discovers that she is not the only one struggling against
expectations. For Mulan, courage is key in facing the emperor, the enemy,
or a father, as she asks for the right to live a life based on love.
Highly recommended. Ages 10 and up. -- Eileen
Charbonneau
TWILIGHT
OF AVALON
Anna Elliott, Touchstone, 2009,
$16.00, pb, 430pp, 1416589899
In Arthurian fiction, queens tend
to fall into two groups: the powerful and the powerless. Anna Elliott
places Isolde among the latter. To a large extent this is because she sets
her version of the story of Trystan (as she calls him here) and Isolde in
a brutal Dark Age (6th-century) Britain. It is Isolde’s misfortune to have
lost her male protectors at a time when women badly need them, and to make
matters worse she is mistrusted by almost everyone, for is she not the
daughter of Modred, Arthur’s son by incest with his half sister Morgan?
And of Gwynefar, who betrayed her husband? And did not her father’s
rebellion lead to the disaster at Camlann? And is she not a healer like
her grandmother, a reputed sorceress? She was wed to Constantine, Arthur’s
heir, but now he lies dead, and the rulers of Britain, gathered to choose
a successor, view her with suspicion, if not outright
hostility.
Surrounded by enemies, she is forced to
marry the vicious Marche, King of Cornwall, who predictably mistreats her.
She desperately needs a protector, but this is no medieval romance.
Trystan, when he does appear, spends most of his time in a prison cell,
leaving Isolde to struggle desperately for survival, not only for herself
but for all Britain as well, in the fortress of Tintagel and on the wild
moor to which she flees. Indeed, she helps him more than he does
her.
This, the first book of a trilogy, is a dark
vision, inspired by Geoffrey of Monmouth’s account of disunity and
treachery among the British leaders, and it maintains powerful tension
throughout as it exposes the suffering of those affected by their cruelty
and shortsightedness. Strongly recommended.
-- Ray Thompson
THE PHYSICK BOOK OF DELIVERANCE DANE
(US) / THE LOST BOOK OF SALEM (UK)
Katherine Howe, Voice, 2009,
$25.95/C$31.95, hb, 384pp, 9781401340902 / Penguin, 2009, £6.99, pb,
480pp, 9780141038117
This is a story that’s easy to
lose yourself in. It alternates between the early 1990s, when Connie
Goodwin is working on her doctorate in American colonial history at
Harvard, and the colonial Salem area, mostly in the early 1690s. Connie
has passed her oral exams, and when asked by her mother to ready Connie’s
grandmother’s long vacant house outside of Salem for possible sale, she
decides she can spend the summer fixing up the house while finding a topic
for her dissertation, which she needs to start soon. She has never seen
her grandmother’s house before and is amazed to find it is centuries old,
hidden by overgrowth. Shortly after she arrives, she finds an ancient key
containing an equally old slip of paper with the word
s “Deliverance Dane” written
upon it. Connie is not one to ignore a historical mystery, one which plays out for the reader in the Interlude
sections, in which we get glimpses of the life of Deliverance Dane, her
daughter, and granddaughter. Goody Dane has the misfortune to live at the
time of the Salem witch trials. But what was her role? Why is she not
mentioned in the records of that time?
The alternating time periods do not distract but
rather interplay neatly. The Interludes, while shorter than the 1990s
story, give an atmospheric glimpse into that fraught time and some of its
lingering consequences. In Connie’s sections, the research undertaken by
the chair of the history department, the story of her grandmother’s house,
and the mystery of what happens to the men connected to this house, all
interweave with Connie’s search for Deliverance Dane to create a book that
is impossible to put down.
-- Trudi E.
Jacobson
THE BOOK
OF NIGHT WOMEN
Marlon James, Riverhead, 2009,
$26.95, 432pp, 9781594488573
The Book
of Night Women is a beautifully written, sweeping
tale of Jamaican slavery set in the early 19th century. The
story centers on Lilith, a slave born on the Montpelier Estate, a large
sugar plantation, where life is ruled by danger and fear. Lilith comes of
age and kills a black slave driver who attempts to rape her. This event
marks Lilith from the other slaves, who begin to both fear and revere her
for they sense that she possess a dark power hidden within. Members of a
group which calls itself the Night Women keep their eye on Lilith and
bring her into their secret circle. At their meetings, Lilith learns they
are plotting a slave revolt of massive proportion that involves several
plantations. She hesitates to participate, but the Night Women see her as
a force that could really help their cause, and Lilith is torn between her
feelings.
James portrays his dynamic and flawed
characters in a complex, stratified society where many boundaries, some
known and some unspoken, exist between slaves and their masters as well as
among the slaves themselves. The authentic voice of the narrator, who
remains a mystery until the end, moves the story along at a brisk pace.
Strong language abounds, and the entire novel is written in a slave
dialect which adds to the story, making it a realistic, engaging read.
James portrays the violence as it really was, absolutely horrific, and
does not hold back. One of the most satisfying parts of the novel is
James’s exploration of the power of love to transform one’s thinking. This
tale of freedom, hope, survival, and unlikely love is unique and will
continue to make readers think. Marlon James is an extremely gifted writer
whose next book I eagerly anticipate. -- Troy
Reed
Galway
Bay
Mary Pat Kelly, Grand Central, 2009,
hb, $26.99US/C$29.99/£18.99, 567pp, 0446579009
Ireland, 1848: Blight
has killed the potato crop for the third time in four years, there’s no
work or food, the rents are due, and you are being turned out of your
home. Just as you decide you must escape to America, your beloved husband
dies, leaving you with four young children and another on the way. So what
do you do? If you are Honora Kelly and her sister Maire, you forge ahead,
doing what you must to survive and give your children a better
life.
Mary Pat Kelly’s Galway Bay is based on
her great-great-grandmother’s life, and what a tale it is. Honora Kelly
not only sailed to America with her unconventional sister and their eight
children, but she determinedly dragged them all to Chicago in hopes of
locating her late husband’s brother, Patrick. Once there, Honora and her
sister find work and watch as their sons grow strong in the shadow of the
upcoming Civil War, all the while trying to maintain a sense of their
Irish heritage.
Initially, I wasn’t sure that I
would enjoy Galway Bay; the author spends the first few chapters
being what I thought of as “too Irish”: repeating Irish folklore and using
Irish words so often that it became distracting rather than illuminating.
However, as the story continued, her characters took over the narration
and led me into their lives and hearts; I surprised myself after fifty
pages or so at how drawn into the story I’d become. Kelly does an
admirable job of giving the grim details of The Great Starvation, and her
characters’ desperation for survival literally swept me away. By the end I
was cheering them all on proudly and willing the story never to end. This
is not a pretty tale, but it is ultimately an uplifting one. Highly
recommended. -- Tamela McCann
A QUIET
FLAME
Philip Kerr, Putnam, 2009, $26.95, hb,
389pp, 9780399155307 / Quercus, 2008, £7.99, pb, 448pp,
9781847245588
Framed as a war criminal, ex-SS
officer Bernie Gunther is forced to flee to Argentina with the likes of
Adolph Eichmann for company. He finds that his reputation gained before
the war as a Berlin police detective has preceded him. Bernie is instantly
drafted into Peron’s secret police with a mission to find a missing girl.
The clues lead him to link the disappearance with a murdered girl in 1932,
a case he nearly solved before his investigation was terminated by the
rise of Hitler. Before long he finds evidence that the old nightmares of
his Nazi days have been reborn in the new world. Linking up with a
beautiful, young Jewess, he launches an investigation that puts him in
deadly conflict with both the Peron regime and the Nazi war criminals that
the president so warml
y embraced.
Fifth in a series, this entry loses nothing of the grit and realism that
made its predecessors so entertaining and satisfying. There is still the
wisecracking, sardonic Bernie, fighting for what is right despite the many
ambiguities forced upon him. The sharply drawn
sinister foes are here, too, only this time a plethora of them, from a
veritable who’s-who of escaped Nazi war criminals to the Perons
themselves, including the fabulous Evita.
This is a thinking man’s sort of fiction, one
that transcends its noir genre. The big questions—life and death, guilt or
innocence—are handled in an almost philosophical way. Punishment and
justice are especially elusive and ambiguous, especially when applied to
Bernie himself, who, despite all his efforts to the contrary, finds
himself indelibly tainted by the very bacillus he fights
against.
Philip Kerr has crafted a series of books
that are at once entertaining, informative, and vaguely disturbing. This
latest offering is perhaps the best of all, and it also stands as a
remarkable read on its own. Highly recommended.
-- Ken Kreckel
TUCK:
The Legend Triumphs
Stephen R. Lawhead, Thomas
Nelson Inc., 2009, $26.99, hb, 9781595540874
This is book three in the King
Raven trilogy, the final chapter of Stephen Lawhead’s interpretation of
the Robin Hood legend. During the rule of William Rufus in
12th-century England, the Norman conquerors wanted to control
the rich farmland of Wales, along with the rest of the isle. Before the
arrival of the Normans, the young Bran was to become king of a small realm
within Wales. After his father was killed at the hands of the Norman
invaders, his realm was seized and ruled by a cruel overlord. This novel
begins as Rhi Bran and his band of outlaws, who lived secluded in the
dense forests of the land known as The March, fight to regain control of
his land. One of his men
, a small squat Friar named Tuck, would become
instrumental in trying to regain his throne in this final book of the
trilogy.
Steeped in Celtic
mythology and political intrigue, Tuck is also filled with suspense
and action. The dialog is marvelous, the settings in Wales and England
breathtaking, and the characters well drawn. I have read all three novels
in the series, and really hated to finally end this reading experience,
one that I will always remember; I will probably read these books again. I
highly recommend this series and would strongly advise beginning with the
first book, Hood. I anxiously await Mr. Lawhead’s next release. --
Jeff Westerhoff
THE OWL
KILLERS
Karen Maitland, Michael Joseph, 2009,
£12.99, hb, 595pp, 9780718153205 / Delacorte, Sept. 2009, $25.00, hb,
480pp, 9780385341707
The year is 1321. Deep in the
heart of the English countryside, an isolated village is controlled by a
sinister group called the Owl Masters. A pagan group, they rule by fear,
terrorising the local population with accusations of sin bringing
retribution in the form of horrific death. The status quo is disturbed by
the arrival of a group of religious women who establish a community at the
edge of the village. The Owl Masters, who find their
power being challenged by the women, react violently and, aided by the
corrupt local priest, seek to destroy the community of
Beguines.
The story is told from
the point of view of the main
characters
in the book in a series of small but connected chapters. The tension
builds slowly but subtly with the conflict between the religious community
and the Owl Masters building to a satisfying climax. The writing is taut,
compelling, and atmospheric, evoking the superstitious ignorance of the
age. If you like gothic medieval novels with venal priests, murder,
witches, and strong-minded women, this is for you. I loved it. Definitely
one to keep, and highly recommended.
-- Mike
Ashworth
A BEAUTIFUL
PLACE TO DIE
Malla Nunn, Picador,
2009, £12.99, pb, 399pp, 9780230711211 / Atria, 2009, $25.00, hb, 384pp,
9781416586203
South Africa, 1952.
Detective Sergeant Emmanuel Cooper is sent to investigate the murder of
Afrikaner police officer Captain Willem Pretorius in the remote town of
Jacob’s Rest. As Emmanuel digs deeper into Pretorius’s double life, he
must also stay one step ahead of the dead man’s thuggish sons and Security
Branch officers intent on pinning the murder on black political
activists.
Although this novel
is gritty and hard-hitting (sometimes literally), there is a seam of dry
humour running through which prevents it from becoming too grim. This is
most obvious in the characterisation of Hansie Hepple, the white teenage
constab
le whose complete indoctrination in the
idea of white supremacy makes him blind to where the
evidence is pointing. Yet, according to the absurd race laws, he outranks
the black constable, Shabalala, despite the latter’s greater experience
and phenomenal observational and tracking skills.
This may be Nunn’s first novel, but her
experience as an award-winning screenwriter is obvious in the confident
way she creates characters, evokes the setting, and structures the plot so
that there is no letup in the tension until the very last page. I’ll
definitely keep my eye open for her next book.
-- Jasmina Svenne
The Last
Dickens
Matthew Pearl, Random House,
2009, $25.00, hb, 381pp, 9781400066568 / Harvill Secker, 2009,
£12.99,
hb, 384pp, 9781846550843
If you love reading Charles
Dickens, this novel will be heaven-sent. If you’re not a big fan of
Dickens, you will be after reading this novel. It’s that good and
that much fun.
This erudite literary mystery has
action and colorful characters galore, both historical and fictional, and
includes flashbacks to Dickens’s tour of America in 1867 that demonstrate
his extreme fame, the public’s love for him, and the protective love his
confidants and entourage had for him as well. It’s a rousing story of
murder, the opium trade, and the cutthroat 19th-century
publishing business. With action taking place in India, England, Boston,
and other U.S. sites, the author maintains seemingly distinct storylines.
Just when you think they will never gel and make sense, Pearl brilliantly
links them together.
The book revolves around
Dickens’s unfinished last novel, The Mystery of Edwin Drood. After
Dickens’s death in 1870, his Boston publisher, James R. Osgood, sets off
on a journey to England to find if rumored additional chapters really
existed. He fights off opium dealers and thugs hired by rival publishers,
gains the trust of Dickens’s family members, and tangles with a villain of
mythic proportions. All this action might sound overblown, but it’s a
literary romp through 19th century culture and its seamiest
sides, not unlike much of Dickens’s work. It’s well written and chock full
of details on Dickens and his times. This reviewer might question why the
character of Osgood’s companion and love interest is relatively
undeveloped, but this is a minor quibble. Highly recommended. --
Pamela Ortega
SILENT
ON THE MOOR
Deanna Raybourn, Mira, 2009,
$13.95/C$13.95, pb, 544pp, 978077832614 / Mira, 2009, £6.99, pb, 558pp,
9780778303046
Widowed Lady Julia Grey returns
in this third outing to openly pursue Nicholas Brisbane, a private
investigator she first encountered over her husband’s corpse. Her pursuit
takes her to Yorkshire, where Brisbane has been gifted an estate. A book
set in the 19th century on the Yorkshire moors begs for a hero
as brooding as Heathcliff, and Brisbane is that. He is as determined to
rebuff Julia as she is to make him admit his feelings for her. All manner
of obstacles conspire against the couple: Brisbane’s half-Gypsy side and
his renunciation of the Sight (which comes with punishing headaches), the
widowed mother and daughters who have lost their family home to him and
are
dependent on his charity, and Lady Julia’s gruesome
discovery among their dead brother’s Egyptian artifacts.
This third installment is eminently satisfying.
It departs from the first two in that although narrated by Julia again,
the focus is on Brisbane returning to his roots. He shares a past with the
family he has dispossessed, and Julia learns even more about him; neither
of these things affects her love for him. As with the first two books,
plot points abound and yet nothing gets short shrift. I feel inadequate to
the task of conveying how completely engrossing this was. Suffice it to
say, I’m praying Raybourn continues! -- Ellen
Keith
Drood
Dan
Simmons, Little, Brown, 2009, $26.99/C$29.99, hb, 784pp, 9780316007023 /
Quercus, 2009, £14.99, pb, 800pp, 9781847247957
In 1865, Charles
Dickens, returning from a holiday with his mistress and her mother, is
involved in the disastrous railway accident at Staplehurst. As Dickens
wanders through the carnage, helping to tend the injured and dying, he
encounters a strange figure, calling himself “Drood.” But who is Drood? Is
he a figment of Dickens’s imagination? Or that of the narrator, Dickens’s
friend and literary rival, the opium-addicted Wilkie Collins? Or that of
Inspector Field, the detective who claims that Drood is a master criminal
who must be brought to justice?
Normally, I prefer
my fiction straightforward, with a reliable narrator bringing us smoothly
from point A to point B, but Drood was a delightful exception for
me. Reliable or not, Collins is a vastly entertaining narrator, who, when
he is not fretting about Drood and the ever-present Inspector Field, is
shuttling between his rival mistresses, gulping copious amounts of
laudanum, and grousing about his friend Dickens’s greater success as a
novelist (though, as Collins never tires of reminding us, his last effort
outsold Dickens’).
As befits a novel with Dickens as
a major character, Drood is a doorstopper of a book, with a vast
number of characters, most of them historical. Though the novel by no
means feels top-heavy with historical facts, Simmons appears to have
omitted no detail of Dickens’s last years, with even a doomed dog of
Dickens making several appearances. The dialogue is sharp, with each
character having a distinct voice, and the descriptive writing is vivid,
with the grisly Staplehurst scenes being particularly
memorable.
Familiarity with Dickens and his works
isn’t a prerequisite for enjoying Drood, though it certainly adds
to the reader’s pleasure. Those wanting a thoroughly original, deftly
written novel should make haste to read this one.
-- Susan Higginbotham
THE HELP
Kathryn Stockett, Putnam, 2009,
$24.95/C$27.50, hb, 464pp, 9780399155345 / Fig Tree, 2009, £12.99, hb,
464pp, 9781905490431
In
1962 in Jackson, Mississippi, Skeeter, a young white aspiring journalist,
comes home from Ole Miss and decides to document the struggles of
African-American maids. The clandestine project becomes a catalyst for
change and impacts the lives of many women, black and white. Not only Jim
Crow laws and racial bias, but class prejudice and gender roles are
exposed in all their ugliness.
The story is told in
three first-person voices, that of Skeeter and of two of the maids she
interviews, Minny and Aibileen. Talking honestly to Skeeter about their
struggles is an act of courage on the part of Minny, Aibileen, and the
other women they recruit for the project. Skeeter herself must re-examine
the relationship she had with the maid who helped to raise her, and look
at her own position in society. As Skeeter grows into an independent woman
and a brave journalist, it becomes increasingly clear to her that the
lines that divide people
are artificial. Minny and Aibileen, who
risk far more than Skeeter does, find deep inner resources and evolve as
people. The characters’ internal struggles and the external danger from
white supremacists charge this novel with enormous dramatic tension and
make it practically impossible to put down.
The
Help abounds in vividly drawn female characters. Skeeter, Minny, and
Aibileen’s voices ring true. The maids’ employers emerge as fully
believable people. Some are petty tyrants, but Stockett draws a touching,
humorous portrait of Miss Celia, Minny’s boss, decent at the core but
adrift from her poor, country roots and floundering. This brilliantly
written novel has wonderful comic moments as well as heartbreak. I’d
put it on the top of my bookshelf, next to To Kill A Mockingbird.
It is that extraordinary. -- Phyllis T. Smith
Top
of
Page