historical

novel

society

 

Editors'
Choice
Titles


For each quarterly issue of the Historical Novels Review, the editors will select a small number of titles they feel exemplify the best in historical fiction.  These novels, which come highly recommended from our reviewers, have been designated as Editors' Choice titles. The reviews are reprinted in full, below.
To read all 200-odd reviews published in this issue, please subscribe!

The Historical Novel Society

    Home / About Us
    Definition of Historical Fiction
    Solander Magazine
    Historical Novels Review
    Annual Conferences
    Join the Society

HNS Online

    Newsletter
    Discussion List
    Nominate Best Novel
    Forthcoming Historical Novels
    Our Members' Websites
    Member News

Ad Rates | Contact | Links

 

© 2005  Historical Novel Society  All Rights Reserved

If you love historical fiction, please JOIN the society today.  You won't be sorry.

'I've just read Solander - it's a triumph!'  - Bernard Cornwell.

Editors' Choice Titles for November 2005:

[View complete Table of Contents]

THE DEATH OF ACHILLES
Boris Akunin, Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2005, £12.99, hb, 330pp, 0297645536
Those of you who have read any of the other three novels by Boris Akunin already available in English will need no encouragement to read this latest work to be translated from Russian.  Yes, Erast Fandorin is back, more like James Bond than ever, complete with the Japanese manservant with whom he practises martial arts in his hotel bedroom.  But of course Fandorin is also a master sleuth, Bond with the deductive powers of Sherlock Holmes.  This time he is back in Moscow in 1879 investigating the sudden death of the military hero, General Sobolev.
    The first half of the book is classic Fandorin, a swashbuckling romp in elegant, measured prose.  Then halfway through the story changes tack.  The second half is written not from the viewpoint of Fandorin but from the viewpoint of the assassin.  Whodunnit becomes how-does-he-get-caught, and in the process it becomes a deeper, more psychological thriller.
    It took me a while to adjust, but it worked.  There are still more Fandorin books out there in Russia, and I am sure that there are many like me who are looking forward to their arrival in the English speaking world.
--Edward James

THE OLD BUZZARD HAD IT COMING
Donis Casey, Poisoned Pen Press, 2005, $24.95, hb, 220pp, 1590581490
Mystery readers everywhere, rejoice! This first of the Alafair Tucker mysteries introduces an engaging new heroine to treasure. Set during the cold winter of 1912 on the Oklahoma frontier, Alafair Tucker is a farm wife and mother of nine. She determines to discover the murderer of an abusive neighbor, even when the clues point to his eldest son, whom Alafair’s daughter Phoebe loves and who is hiding in one of the family’s outbuildings.

    Don’t be misled by the unfortunate title and cover design. Casey’s novel brims with wit, humor and the occasional devastating sorrow. Alafair and Shaw and their wholesome brood stand in sharp contrast to the murdered man and his family. Their children run through household duties as if sired by the Gold Shoe bunny so their mom can work her investigation around the authorities and the expectations that she’ll stay within her female sphere. She works those expectations to her own advantage. Alafair is naturally curious, wise, and a bit too courageous for her own good now and then, when she’s also lucky. If the wholesome meter gets to tipping, a welcome touch of magical realism saves the novel from sentimentality. A deep pleasure to read, and a few of Alafair’s recipes are included! I can’t wait for the next adventure of this original new sleuth. Highly recommended.
--
Eileen Charbonneau

THE MARCH
E. L. Doctorow, Random House, 2005, $25.95/C$35.95, hb, 365pp, 0375506713
To be pub. in the UK by Little Brown, 2006, £10.99, pb, 384pp, 0316731986
The March unfolds in sporadic episodes in the same manner as this historic military maneuver wended its way through Georgia and the Carolinas at the end of the War Between the States. As inhuman as the bare facts are when taken at face value, we learn enough about General William Tecumseh Sherman and his personal demons to understand, sympathize with, and admire him as both man and general. As the march progresses, we meet soldiers of both armies, including a pair of Confederate misfits who conveniently wear either uniform. Among the stragglers and followers are women who have lost husbands, sons, homes, their purpose in life. We meet Mattie Jameson, a widow, seeking her two sons taken as adolescents into the Confederate army; Emily Thompson, daughter of a Southern judge, who has a brief involvement with Colonel Sartorious, an outstanding Union Army surgeon; and Pearl, a beautiful half-white, freed slave on the brink of womanhood and searching for her destiny.
    This is vintage Doctorow. His sympathetic portrayal of the havoc and destruction wreaked on a helpless civilian population is brilliant. His insight into the suffering, both civilian and military, is compassionate. The March is a forceful and mesmerizing literary novel.
--Audrey Braver

THE CONSTANT PRINCESS
Philippa Gregory, Touchstone, 2005, $24.95, hb, 375 pp, 074327248X
Pub. in the UK by HarperCollins, 2005, £17.99, hb, 0007190301
From infancy, Catalina, Infanta of Spain, daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella, has been groomed to be the Queen of England. She travels to England as a young girl, torn out of her familiar surroundings, not speaking English, and thrust into a world she cannot fathom. Yet she has the presence of mind, the rearing and the maturity to cope with everything and anything that is thrown at her. She never forgets that she is to be Queen of England someday. That is her one and only goal. It is by the strength of her character, her resilience and her talent that she discovers a way to make that goal a reality.
The facts are well known, but the way that Gregory tells the story is a wonder. The transformation from the young Catalina to the mature Katherine of Aragon, dryly recounted in our history books, comes to life in Gregory’s talented hands. Moving between third-party narrative and personal revelations by Catalina, we are made privy to the Infanta’s tortured introduction into English life, her love affair with her once-despised husband, Arthur, her widowhood, and her machinations leading her to the throne of England by marriage to the feisty, immature Henry, Arthur’s brother.
    The most recent in Gregory’s magnificent Tudor novels, this is a terrific book and a must read.
--Ilysa Magnus

THE WIDOW OF THE SOUTH
Robert Hicks, Warner, 2005, $24.95/C$33.95, hb, 414pp, 0446500127
Pub. in the UK by Bantam, 2006, £10.99, pb, 416pp, 059305590X
"The widow of the South" is Carrie McGavock, the wife of a Tennessee plantation owner who, in 1864, finds her house commandeered as a field hospital by Confederate general Nathan Bedford Forrest. After the Battle of Franklin, wounded men cram every square foot of Carnton’s stately rooms. Numbed by the deaths of three children and her emotional separation from her husband, Carrie discovers purpose in caring for the remains of a decimated army. Time spent with one of the injured men, Arkansas sergeant Zachariah Cashwell, helps her heal wounds from her past, and she goes on to arrange the interment of almost 1,500 soldiers on her property.
     A note from the publisher compares this novel to Cold Mountain and Gone with the Wind. When I read these types of claims, I usually smile skeptically, but in the case of The Widow of the South, the hype is warranted. This is an intensely moving and wholly believable novel. Hicks crafts his characters with care, resulting in people we learn to care about, too.
     If, like me, you’re not particularly interested in the American Civil War, read The Widow of the South. It offers what is found in only the best historical fiction: a story so irresistibly attractive that you decide upon finishing it to go out and read everything that’s ever been written about the events that inspired it.
--Claire Morris

IN LUCIA’S EYES
Arthur Japin, translated from the Dutch by David Colmer, Chatto and Windus, 2005, £12.99, hb, 247pp, 070117795. 
Pub. in the US by Knopf, 2005, $24.00, hb, 256pp, 1400044642
In Amsterdam, 1758, a masked courtesan captures the attention of Monsieur le Chevalier de Seingalt – who will later come to be known as Casanova.  In the hope of becoming Galathee de Pompignac’s lover, Seingalt makes a wager with her that she will be unable to find a single woman whose heart he has broken.
     What Seingalt doesn’t know is that Galathee is none other than his first love, Lucia, the girl he planned to marry before she left without a word.  Lucia’s disappearance crushed him and he never discovered that she had contracted smallpox and run away because of her horrible disfigurement.  Now years later Galathee knows she can win the wager and becomes his lover again, accepting that one day the affair will finish and she will once more lose the love of her life.
Arthur Japin has taken a brief reference to Lucia in Casanova’s memoirs and expanded it into a tale of tragedy and heartbreak.  The resulting novel is a delightful portrait of 18th century Amsterdam and a study of enduring love.  The author deserves the many plaudits and prizes lavished on his work in Europe.  Congratulations must also go to David Colmer who seamlessly translated the novel into English from the original Dutch.  His is a triumphant achievement that avoids the stiffness and lack of sensitivity that has ruined many a translation before now.  In Lucia’s Eyes is a literary work that should appeal to the romantic in us all.
--Sara Wilson

JOSEPH AND HIS BROTHERS
Thomas Mann, Everyman’s Library, 2005, $42.00/C$55.00/£25.00, hb, 1492pp, 1400040019 (US/Can), 1857152875 (UK)
The plot of this book is familiar, a more or less chronological rendering of a portion of Genesis. Thomas Mann’s hefty tome is not just the story of Joseph and his brothers (the favored son with the coat of many colors sold into slavery in Egypt by jealous siblings), but also the story of Joseph's father, Jacob. We read of Jacob stealing his brother Esau’s birthright and then fleeing to his Uncle Laban’s home, where the well-known saga of Leah and Rachel unfolds. The book does not truly become Joseph’s until he arrives in Egypt and begins his rise and eventual fall because of Potiphar’s lovesick wife. Then Joseph the dream interpreter, favored by God, rises again to become Pharaoh’s right-hand man, saving the Egyptians from famine. His starving brothers come to buy food. After toying with them a bit, Joseph reveals himself to them, explaining how it was all part of God’s plan. Of course, the Bible fleshes out this brief summary, but the Bible leaves a lot open to speculation, particularly any psychological insights into the motivation of the main actors.
    Joseph and His Brothers
leaves nothing out. Thomas Mann wants to illuminate the story’s significance from every angle, examining every detail, even those details that are necessarily obscure. Still reeling from the experience, I believe he succeeds. This is an extraordinary book. Despite its length, its detours, and the fact that I always knew more or less what was going to happen next, I was never bored. In a new translation by John E. Woods it is surprisingly readable, subtly humorous at times, challenging, and ultimately rewarding. It is by far the best book I have read in years.
--Sue Asher

INDISCRETION
Jude Morgan, Headline Review, 2005, £10.99, hb, 378pp, 075530764X
You might think that to call your heroine Miss Fortune would handicap her, but Caroline Fortune is too strong a character for that. When her eccentric father loses all his money gambling, Caroline is forced to seek employment. She becomes companion to a positive gorgon of a rich old lady and is immediately embroiled in her employer’s feud with her niece and nephew. Caroline enjoys Brighton society, as much as Mrs Catling allows her to, and there meets an attractive man who does not, as she supposes, wish to offer her honourable love, but to make her his mistress. She keeps the humiliating proposition to herself. Even when she leaves Mrs Catling and finds a welcome in the home of a long lost aunt, she keeps her own counsel. Caroline soon makes friends and is accepted in this new milieu, but to her horror she finds her ungallant suitor from Brighton is the fiancé of her new best friend. which puts her in a dilemma. How she copes with this difficult situation and finally finds someone she can truly love ends this stylishly written, engaging story.
    The characters are wonderfully drawn—some seem to have stepped out from the pages of Jane Austen, others from those of Georgette Heyer. This is the best Regency I have come across for a long time.
--Pamela Cleaver

THIS THING OF DARKNESS (US Title: TO THE EDGE OF THE WORLD)
Harry Thompson, Headline Review, 2005, £12.99, hb, 626pp, 075530280X
Pub. in the US by MacAdam/Cage, 2006, $26.00, hb, 800pp, 1596921900
In 1831, HMS Beagle set out on her now-famous second voyage, to complete the Admiralty’s survey of the South American coast. Her captain was the brilliant young officer Robert Fitzroy, who had hired a cleric-in-training to be his intellectual companion and the ship’s naturalist. This Thing of Darkness is the story of that voyage and its consequences for both Fitzroy and his ‘scientific gentleman,’ Charles Darwin. The two men got on well, despite their contrasting temperaments (Fitzroy was a complex manic-depressive, Darwin a relatively easygoing optimist) and backgrounds (Fitzroy was a minor aristocrat, a descendant of Charles II, while Darwin belonged to a family of nonconformist entrepreneurs and intellectuals). But Darwin’s researches gradually led him into religious doubts, and began to seem to Fitzroy like attacks on his own fundamentalist Christianity. Lest this should all seem too dry-as-dust, Thompson has skilfully woven the conflict of ideas between Fitzroy and Darwin into a tapestry of danger, adventure, tragedy and satire, a story with a terrific sense of period and place, peopled with memorable characters, major and minor. Especially poignant are the tragicomic Fuegians, whom Fitzroy had brought back to England o
n a previous voyage in order to ‘civilise’ them, returning them on this voyage to Tierra del Fuego so that their compatriots might ‘catch’ civilisation from them.
Judging from the lengthy bibliography provided, Thompson did a prodigious amount of research, and it’s greatly to his credit that it enriches, but never overwhelms, the story. It’s hard to believe that this highly-accomplished novel is the first from an author better known as a biographer of Peter Cook and producer of the TV show Have I Got News For You. Deservedly Booker-longlisted, This Thing of Darkness is by far the best historical novel I’ve read all year—an engrossing, thought-provoking page-turner that entertained me for hours on end and showed me many wonders.
--
Sarah Cuthbertson

THE CRAZYLADIES OF PEARL STREET
Trevanian, Crown, 2005, $24.95/C$34.95, hb, 384pp, 14000080363
As someone who has lived in the Albany, New York, area much of her life, I was unable to pass up this memoir cum novel set downtown on Pearl Street in the late 1930s and early 1940s. Six year old Jean-Luc LaPointe and his younger sister have been brought to poverty-stricken North Pearl Street by their mother. Their long-absent father has found them an apartment, and, for once, they will all live as a family. When Jean-Luc, Anne-Marie and their mother arrive, they find the kitchen decorated for a St. Patrick’s Day party, with green streamers and green soda, and a note from their father saying he’s just gone out to buy a green cake to make the celebration complete. He never returns.
    Jean-Luc is nearing the end of his life as he narrates the story of his family’s tribulations, and occasional joys, through the eyes of his younger self. The Depression has had a tremendous impact on the families of North Pearl Street, and we live with the LaPointes as they scrimp and manage as best they can. One extravagance that enlivens their lives immeasurably is a battered Emerson radio they buy on installment from the local pawn shop. The novel is suffused by the popular culture of the time: the radio shows and characters that Jean-Luc incorporates into his “story games,” the movie stars and the songs of the period. This is the Albany that William Kennedy writes about, and the Democratic machine is alive and well in Trevanian’s tale. In fact, Kennedy and Trevanian grew up at the same time just a few blocks from each other, assuming that Trevanian is Rodney Whitaker, who lived at the same Pearl Street address as Jean-Luc. I encourage readers to enter Jean-Luc’s richly described world—you’ll be glad you did.
--Trudi E. Jacobson

UP FROM ORCHARD STREET
Eleanor Widmer, Bantam, 2005, $23.00, hb, 390pp, 0553804006
The 1930s lower East Side of Manhattan comes to brimming life in this novel/memoir. Told from the precocious viewpoint of nine-year-old Elka Roth, the odd duck of her three-generation family, we meet the people of her Jewish neighborhood and the melting pot city around it. Characters, both major and minor, come to immediate life. Widmer’s details, from the squalor of the slum that is the family home to the delicacies wrought by her beloved grandmother, leap from the page.
     Although besieged by crisis, sickness, poverty and their own frailty, the Roths live each moment with a zest and intensity that is the envy of uptown relatives, country vacationers and their constantly fretting team of doctors. Manya, the family founder and open-hearted nurturer, rises above all. A wonderful woman’s extreme adventure story of endurance that can take its place proudly beside The Color Purple, Jane Eyre, and the work it most resembles in setting and tone, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. Highly recommended.
--Eileen Charbonneau

Top of Page