historical

novel

society

 

Editors'
Choice
Titles


For each quarterly issue of the Historical Novels Review, the editors will select a small number of titles they feel exemplify the best in historical fiction.  These novels, which come highly recommended from our reviewers, have been designated as Editors' Choice titles. The reviews are reprinted in full, below.
To read all 200-odd reviews published in this issue, please subscribe!

The Historical Novel Society

    Home / About Us
    Definition of Historical Fiction
    Solander Magazine
    Historical Novels Review
    Annual Conferences
    Join the Society

HNS Online

    Newsletter
    Discussion List
    Nominate Best Novel
    Forthcoming Historical Novels
    Our Members' Websites
    Member News

Ad Rates | Contact | Links

 

© 2008  Historical Novel Society  All Rights Reserved

If you love historical fiction, please JOIN the society today.  You won't be sorry.

'I've just read Solander - it's a triumph!'  - Bernard Cornwell.

Editors' Choice Titles for November 2008:

[Table of Contents] [Aug 2008] [May 2008] [Feb 2008] [Nov 2007] [Aug 2007]
[May 2007] [Feb 2007] [Nov 2006] [Aug 2006] [May 2006] [Feb 2006]
[Nov 2005]

THE OUTLANDER
Gil Adamson, Ecco, 2008, $25.95/C$29.95, hb, 400pp, 9780061491252 / Bloomsbury, 2008, £10.99, pb, 400pp, 9780747596851
    This captivating story opens with a 19-year-old widow running for her life through the woods of western Canada, sometime in the early 20th century. “The widow,” as she is called throughout most of the book, is Mary Boulton, who killed her husband and is being sought by his twin brothers, who are big, burly, and mean men set on revenge. 
    Her full story is revealed over the course of the novel through her encounters with other outlaws and social and political misfits. A shy child whose mother died from a drawn-out illness, Mary yearns to be loved but is ignored by her grieving father and pious grandmother. When John Boulton appears at a party, clearly seeking a wife, she is drawn to him as a fellow outsider; with only this in common they are married, and she moves with him to his shack deep in the forest. John is abusive and a liar, furthering Mary’s sense of being unloved. She feels she is slowly going mad, and indeed it is impossible to tell at times what is really happening and what is a hallucination.
    Adamson successfully uses this technique to reveal much of Mary’s inner self and back story, combining background on the stifling and absurd treatment of women at the time with the reality and dangers of backwoods life. When Mary stops running, she finds herself in a tiny mining town with more than its share of misfits, from the minister to the apothecary to the occasional visitor. Here, finally, her story can turn to one of growth and redemption rather than instinct and fear.
    In her first novel, Adamson has created a marvelously readable tale with memorable characters and an inspiring final narrative twist, all of which makes me look forward to her future work. --
Helene Williams

The Journey
H. G. Adler (trans. Peter Filkins), Random House, 2008, $26.00/C$30.00, hb, 320pp, 9781400066735
    In the introduction of The Journey the translator writes, “Neither Germany nor the world was ready for novels about the Holocaust in the 1950s.” This book, the work of H.G. Adler, a German Jew writer, philosopher, and poet, is the translation of one of only four novels written by survivors of the Holocaust.  It was not published in Germany until 1961.  Based on his personal experiences in the “slave community” of Theresienstadt and in Auschwitz, the novel tells the heartbreaking story of the Lustig family: Leopold, a hardworking doctor; his kind-hearted wife, Caroline; their children, Zerlina and Paul; and Caroline’s sister, Ida.  The novel opens when they are told that they must leave their home to work in the fictitious slave community of Ruhenthal.  Adler writes: “No one asked you, it was decided already.  You were rounded up and not one kind word was spoken… Yet the tight-lipped grins remain unforgettable.”
    Delving beyond the particular hardships of this family, Adler also describes life in the little towns around Ruhenthal and the progressive breakdown of the society at large when in the hands of a totalitarian state.  Civility and justice are destroyed first.  Denial is pervasive, in and out of the camps.  With their wills broken, the condemned cling to the hope that “only the stupid ones are beaten,” that “only the bad ones are shot.” The people in the towns regard them as “loafers… led by a military honor guard.” Adler makes you squirm in disgust and discomfort, when he switches tenses, narrative voices, pointing fingers at the readers, addressing us as victims or as executioners, and throwing Kafkaesque twists of metamorphosis and madness.  After Auschwitz, the introduction reminds us, critics believed that literature was no longer possible.  Adler believed that it was not only possible, but necessary.  Writing this astounding novel, Adler amply proved his point. --
Adelaida Lower

THE BLACK TOWER
Louis Bayard, Morrow, 2008, $24.95/C$26.95, hb, 368pp, 9780061173509
    In 1818, a street beggar follows Hector Carpentier to his home in the Latin Quarter, only to transform himself into Vidocq, Paris’s master detective. What does Vidocq want with Hector, whose life with his drab mother, a trio of loutish student lodgers, and an elderly boarder is a model of law-abiding obscurity? The answer puts Vidocq and the reluctant Hector on the trail of a lost prince—Marie Antoinette’s young son Louis-Charles, supposed to have died in captivity during the Revolution. Along the way, Hector will learn some startling truths about his family and acquaintances—and about himself—all while trying to evade the men who suddenly want him dead.
    This was my first go at reading a novel by Bayard, and won’t be my last. Bayard’s writing is exceptionally good: clever yet unpretentious, with wonderful turns of phrase that made me go back and re-read passages for the sheer enjoyment of it. The characters drawn from real life (including Vidocq himself) are vivid, as are fictitious ones like Hector (the narrator) and his motley companions. Even the minor characters are sharply rendered. Best of all, perhaps, is the manner in which Bayard portrays the plight of young Louis-Charles, with a self-assured combination of anger, compassion, and wit that is moving yet never maudlin.
    Thanks to these qualities, readers of historical fiction, literary fiction, and mystery should all thoroughly enjoy this novel. --
Susan Higginbotham

THE SIN EATERS
Andrew Beahrs, Toby, 2008, $24.95/C$24.95/£14.99, hb, 238pp, 9781592642366
    Set in Jacobean England, The Sin Eaters follows the path of the herbalist Sarah, runaway wife Mary, and outcast Bill away from Monkshead and the murderous hold of Sam Ridley, a land clearing master, and toward the coastal city of Northam, their place of reckoning and possible flight to the New World.
    Haunted Sarah sets the plot in motion when she claims revenge on Ridley for his exacting punishment on her as a scold. She flees with donkey, cow and provisions and soon finds fellow sufferer Bill, stripped naked and abused after being tricked into becoming a sin eater—a pariah who consumes food offerings placed overnight on corpses. Sarah devises a way to convince him that his body is once again his own and not a receptacle of the sins of others. 
    As the two travel toward the sea, they take on Mary, a gentlewoman who has been gambled away to a clockmaker. Mary helps them find refuge on her mother’s estate. But Ridley finds them there and bides his time as he plans to exact his revenge. Mary runs off with a member of the household. Sarah’s knowledge of herbs enables escape, and she and Bill reach Northam, but the enraged Ridley finds them at the shoreline between worlds.
    In language that is dense, intimate, and beautiful, Andrew Beahrs’s richly imagined novel travels though meadow, forest, plague-flagged town, and ruined monastery. It is peopled by characters brimming with life. Sarah, attempting to live her remaining years touched by grace and wonder, is unforgettable. Highly recommended. --
Eileen Charbonneau  

GUERNICA
Dave Boling, Bloomsbury USA, 2008, $26.00, hb, 384pp, 9781596915633 / Picador, Feb. 2009, 12.99, hb, 384pp, 9780330460651
    In April 1937, the small Spanish town of Guernica, the center of Basque culture and tradition in Spain, was destroyed by German bombers as a prelude to World War II, a total war devised by the German Luftwaffe. Strongman Justo Ansotegui and his two brothers, along with Miguel Navarro and his brother Dodo, emerge as central characters as the Spanish Civil War forces itself upon their community. Justo’s wife and their daughter, Miren, both charismatic and graceful dancers, add elements of both love and compassion to this story of war and tragedy. A blind girl, Alaia Aldecoa, befriends Miren and demonstrates her independence and will to survive during this terrible time.
    In his debut novel, Dave Boling does an excellent job in drawing out the characters’ personalities. He cleverly fictionalizes historical events by mixing in living people such as Franco, Picasso, and German flying ace Baron von Richthofen. As you read this marvelous story, you can feel the emotion and joy of the Basque culture as it spreads through the community via its music and religion, the sadness and despair after the attack on Guernica, and the characters’ fortitude as they try to recover after losing their loved ones and then attempt to rebuild their town and their lives. I highly recommend this exceptional novel about one of the world’s great tragedies. --
Jeff Westerhoff

THE SEAMSTRESS
Frances De Pontes Peebles, Harper, 2008, $25.95/C$27.95, hb, 646pp, 9780060738877 / Bloomsbury, 2009, £12.99, pb, 656pp, 9780747596868
    Orphaned at a young age, sisters Emilia and Luzia dos Santos are raised by their Aunt Sofia, a seamstress in the town of Taquaritinga do Norte in Brazil. A childhood fall from a tree causes a severe injury to Luzia’s arm, locking the joint at the elbow. Neighborhood children taunt Luzia by calling her Victrola, after the bent arm of the record player. The accident, combined with the mistreatment, causes Luzia to become more introverted—a contrast to her sunny, often flippant sister, who adores celebrity magazines and has a crush on her sewing teacher. When a group of cangaceiros—bandits living in the scrubland in the wilds of Pernambuco state—raid Taquaritinga, their leader, The Hawk, senses that Luzia is a kindred spirit. When The Hawk offers Luzia the opportunity to leave with the cangaceiros, she accepts, knowing that there is little for her in Taquaritinga.
    After Luzia leaves, Emilia meets Degas Coelho, a young law student with a secret to hide. He offers to marry her and take her to Recife, providing the glamorous life she has always dreamed about. Emilia finds that big-city life is more difficult than she had expected, and Degas’s secret life becomes more difficult to hide. As Luzia and The Hawk become increasingly notorious for their violent criminal activities, Emilia wonders if her own secret—that her sister is the cangaceira known as The Seamstress—will be revealed, destroying the life that she has carefully constructed.
    In The Seamstress, Peebles brings the history and culture of a part of the world rarely visited in English-language historical fiction. The pace of social, political, and technological change in Brazil during the early 20th century was rapid, and Emilia and Luzia’s story traces two women’s journey through these revolutionary times. The alternating viewpoints allow readers to follow both sisters’ journeys, both physical and emotional, and make the parallels between their very different lives even more intriguing. This accomplished first novel is highly recommended for all readers of historical fiction.
-- Nanette Donohue

SEAL WOMAN
Solveig Eggerz, Ghost Road Press, 2008, $19.95, pb, 283pp, 9780979625534
    Berlin, 1947. The Icelandic Agricultural Association advertises for “strong women who can cook and do farm work,” and artist Charlotte, who has watched her life and her city crumble around her, agrees to work at a farm called Dark Castle.
   
Seal Woman is, at its core, about the stories we tell ourselves about ourselves, and our lives.  What is real, and what is myth? After almost incomprehensible pain and loss, how does one go on?
    Impressionistic and mythic in the Iceland-based sections, and all too real and present in the Berlin-based sections, the settings–both time and place–are beautifully rendered.  The characters, particularly the protagonist Charlotte, are very real and every bit as frustrating and messy as real people.  I caught myself more than once thinking I was reading the biography of a mid-20th century war survivor.
    But as fascinating as the story and the characters are, the writing itself is gorgeous; many passages are so lovely, I wanted to underline them and commit them to memory so I’d never forget their lyric beauty.  Overall, this is a challenging book on many levels, but very rewarding.  A fantastic story, beautifully written; highly recommended.
-- Julie K. Rose

THE PLAGUE OF DOVES 
Louise Erdrich, Harper, 2008, $25.95/C$27.95, hb, 320pp, 978006051512 / HarperPerennial, 2008, £7.99, pb, 356pp, 9780007270767
   
The Plague of Doves begins in the early 1900s as a group of adventurers head onto the prairie to found a town. Although most starve or freeze, some survive, and the town of Pluto is born. (Passenger pigeons, feasting on the newly planted wheat fields, are the “plague” of the title.) The Ojibwa are remnants of a wilder time, too, serving as convenient scapegoats for the gruesome murder of an isolated farm family. Three generations, on the reservation and off, will be affected by this crime and the lynching which follows.
    Although the mystery is solved in the final pages, the book initially appears to be a collection of interwoven family stories, each with a marvelously realized narrator. We meet wily, witty Mooshum, and his granddaughter, Evelina, an intelligent and passionate young woman who is determined to escape the reservation. There is the Peace family: beautiful Maggie, mad Billy, Shamengwa the violinist, and the delinquent Corwin. We learn how reservation and town are linked inextricably by marriage, adultery, and history. The characters are exquisitely drawn, and the language is an almost magical wedding of poetry to prose. Although The Plague of Doves is a literary novel, it pulses with the warm blood of daily life. There is even, despite high tragedy, a good helping of laugh-out-loud humor. Beautiful and highly recommended! --
Juliet Waldron

Broken Wing
Judith James, Medallion, 2008, $7.95/C$8.95, pb, 432pp, 9781933836447
    When I think of what constitutes a superior historical romance, I think of real characters connecting on many levels with a believable setting that pulls me into the story and sweeps me along into another place and time.  Judith James’s novel Broken Wing is such a tale; I was hooked from the first pages and found myself sighing with satisfaction at the end. 
    In this novel set in France and England in 1800, Lady Sarah Monroe and her brother Lord Huntington have retrieved their youngest brother from a French brothel five years after his kidnapping.  It is due to the care of prostitute Gabriel St. Croix that young Jamie escaped a dastardly fate, and the siblings’ gratitude is so heartfelt that they invite Gabriel to come to England with them. Once home, Gabriel and Sarah begin to feel an attraction that is both inappropriate and undeniable.  After giving in to their feelings, the lovers are soon separated as Gabriel leaves to privateer to earn his fortune; fate intervenes and tragedy ensues. 
   
Broken Wing is both well-written and compelling, and I found the pages flying by as I wrapped myself in the tale of the numb Gabriel being brought to life by the vivacious Sarah. Despite my misgivings over the cliché of Sarah, a countess, wearing men’s breeches, I found there was much to love about this story of two star-crossed lovers finding one another in many ways. Superior reading indeed. -- Tamela McCann

ANGEL OF BROOKLYN
Janette Jenkins, Chatto and Windus, 2008, £16.99, hb, 327pp, 9780701181932
    Jonathan Crane returns to his small home village on the cusp of the First World War with a beautiful wife, Beatrice. Her mysterious and exotic childhood in Normal, Illinois, sets her apart from the village wives and, when the men depart for war, her sense of desperation and isolation increase.
    Her blond hair, smart clothes and accent make the local women wary of her, in spite of her continuing friendly overtures. Her life story interests and repels them, but the one story she will never tell is of how she became the Angel of Brooklyn. But secrets aren’t possible in a close-knit community, and when the truth is revealed the women unite against Beatrice; tragedy is the only possible outcome.
    In Beatrice Crane, Janette Jenkins has created a heroine as colourful and alien as a bird of paradise. A creature used to warmth, noise and chatter left alone in the cold and drear of the English north is unlikely to thrive, and that sense of doom haunts the pages of the novel.
    This is a fine love story in which the visceral horrors of the war are almost incidental to the mental horrors faced by Beatrice as she tries and fails to gain acceptance. The final dramatic climax is truly shocking, being both totally unexpected and yet absolutely inevitable. A fantastic and compelling read.
--
Sara Wilson

THE SIEGE
Ismail Kadare (trans. David Bellos), Canongate, 2008, £16.99, hb, 314pp, 9781847670304
    The Ottoman Empire during the 15th century lays siege to a Christian fortress on a plain surrounded by the mountains of Albania.  The Siege tells the story of the weeks and months that follow: the events that unfold within the camp of brightly coloured banners and hastily constructed minarets as tens of thousands of men begin to fill the plain below the citadel. One character in the novel says, ‘You cannot call a country conquered until you conquer its heaven.’ This novel describes how the citadel refused to be conquered, the elation and despair of the battlefield, the constant shifting strategies of war, and the predicament of those whose lives are held in the balance.
    The story is told through the personal narrative of one of the defenders and partly through the eyes of an Ottoman chronicler, Mevla Celebi.  ‘Great massacres always give birth to great books. You will give birth to writing a thundering chronicle redolent with pitch and blood.’
    This gripping narrative of war is also a meditation on human relations, human folly, ambiguities of power, and the meaning of history. The thoughts and sufferings of 15th-century warriors are barely distinguishable from those in our own time.
    The vividly portrayed characters are unforgettable. The technician blunders. The astrologer makes mistakes and is sent below ground. The poet who wanted to see the action suffers for his foolhardy adventure. The harem of women who are attached to the Ottoman Pasha endure and wait. Images leap through writing that is direct and enigmatic, and above all, flawless, beautiful and unpretentious. David Bellos’s translation of The Siege is outstanding.
    This novel is a masterpiece. It is worth noting that in 2005, Ismail Kadare was the first Man Booker International Prize winner. --
Carol McGrath 

THE RIGHT HAND OF THE SUN
Anita Mason, John Murray, 2008, £16.99, hb, 501pp, 9780719520225
    What is the most dramatic and extraordinary adventure ever recorded?  My vote must go to Cortes’s conquest of Mexico in 1521, when 500 Spaniards overthrew a vast and opulent empire, hitherto unknown to Europeans and alien to anything they had ever encountered: the stuff of science fiction rather than history.
    The story has not lacked chroniclers, starting with Cortes himself and including Prescott’s magisterial ‘The Conquest of Mexico’ (1843) and the eyewitness account of Bernal Diaz (1580, Penguin translation 1963).  No novelist could fail with such a story, but what is there new for a modern novelist to say, or in what new way can the story be told?
    Anita Mason tells it from the viewpoints of several different participants, all in the Spanish camp, including Cortes and his interpreter/mistress, Marina.  I found this rather confusing, and understandably Mason cannot match Diaz, who was a footsoldier in that terrible campaign.  Her originality lies in developing the side story of Geronimo, a sailor who was shipwrecked in Mexico ten years before the Conquest and lived there as a slave until he was ransomed by Cortes for a bag of glass beads.  The story of his captivity is imaginatively recreated and gives us a narrator who can understand and sympathise with both the European and Indian cultures. This is an exceptionally good book, the best modern novel on the Conquest of Mexico. You will enjoy this even if you already know the main story, and if you don’t I hope it encourages you to go on and read Diaz. --
Edward James

SASHENKA
Simon Montefiore, Bantam, 2008, £12.99, hb, 533pp, 9780593056370 / Simon & Schuster, 2008, $27.00, hb, 544pp, 9781416595540
    Sashenka Zeitlin is the daughter of a Jewish banker living in St Petersburg. In the winter of 1916, revolution is in the air, and the beautiful, headstrong sixteen-year-old Sashenka is seduced by the ideals of the Bolsheviks. As Comrade Snowfox she plays a dangerous game of double cross and survives a spell of interrogation at the hands of Captain Sagan.
    Twenty years on, Sashenka is happily married to a senior party official with two children; working as a magazine editor, she enjoys the comfortable lifestyle she despised as a teenager. In Stalin’s Russia this is a dangerous time for those who speak out of turn but, as Stalin’s favourite, Sashenka feels that she and her family are safe. When she recklessly embarks on an illicit love affair, she cannot begin to imagine the repercussions that her actions will have for the next two generations of her family.
    In Sashenka Simon Montefiore has brought to life an unforgettable character, one who enchants and inspires. Hers is an intensely moving story that combines history with a totally absorbing plot. It was during ten years of researching twentieth century Russian history that Montefiore found the inspiration for this exceptional novel of love and endurance of the spirit that rises above man’s inhumanity to man.
--
Ann Oughton       

A MERCY
Toni Morrison, Knopf, 2008, $23.95/C$27.95, hb, 176pp, 9780307264237 / Chatto & Windus, 2008, £15.99, hb, 170pp, 9780701180454
    A Mercy takes place in the late 1680s and follows Florens, a young black slave girl suddenly alone and relying on herself for the first time.  Following the death of Sir, she has been entrusted with an important mission:  fetch the blacksmith, long gone from Sir’s Virginia plantation, where he had designed an elaborate wrought iron gate and proved himself a healer.  He is a free black man and the only person the others believe can save the Mistress and, in doing so, preserve their lives on the plantation.  Florens loves him, but she desperately desires to be needed and loved.  Yes, she will find the blacksmith, but will she bring him back?
    The novel illuminates much more about Florens and about those who have also been gathered onto the plantation they’ve come to regard as home.  The full story grows throughout in a narrative revealed by various characters:  Florens, Jacob (“Sir”), Rebekka (“Mistress”), and Florens’s fellow slaves, Lina and Sorrow.  Their voices disclose their unique perspectives and clarify motivations often misconstrued by the others.
    For instance, from Florens we learn she was given freely to Sir by a mother who preferred to keep her son.  From Jacob we learn that he took Florens reluctantly to settle a debt, finally deciding that Rebekka would appreciate a little girl about the place after losing her own.  But from Mistress Rebekka we learn that Florens wasn’t an addition she welcomed at all.
    Toni Morrison’s A Mercy is told in a beautiful yet devastatingly honest way.  Each narrative voice is distinct, adding enormous depth to the whole right down to the last voice with its final poignant message.  It is an outstanding novel. --
Janette King

A Manuscript of ashes
Antonio Muñoz Molina (trans. Edith Grossman), Harcourt, 2008, $25.00, hb, 320pp, 9780151014101
    Resolving to flee the tumult of the university in the late 1960s, Minaya, a young student, decides to leave Madrid and write his doctoral dissertation on Jacinto Solana, a Republican poet who was killed by the Civil Guard after the Spanish Civil War. It so happens that Solana was a friend of his uncle Manuel and that the poet lived in his uncle’s country estate some time before his death. Minaya travels to Mágina, a small town in the south. Although his uncle assures him there is nothing left of Solana’s work, Minaya, with the help of Inés, a young maid, soon discovers that this is not true. His research into Solana’s last days leads him to the poet’s masterpiece, Beatus Ille, and to another unfortunate event that also took place in his uncle’s house—the death of Mariana Rios, the beautiful model who married his uncle, was loved by Solana, and was accidentally shot the day after her wedding.
    First published in 1986 under the evocative title Beatus Ille, this was an early novel of Antonio Muñoz Molina, the renowned author of Sepharad and a member of the Royal Spanish Academy since 1995. Muñoz Molina’s style calls to mind a musical fugue, the writer going back to a word, or a sentence, or a scene, repeating it with a slight variation that gives it an entirely different character.  Introspective, moody, structurally adventurous, symmetrical in theme, A Manuscript of Ashes is an unusual detective story, a novel about unfulfilled desire, uncompleted flights, and lost manuscripts. Muñoz Molina delves as well into the creative impulse, the need to write and rewrite. Readers might be startled by his long paragraphs, meandering points of view, and voices that mingled, but, no doubt, they will also be absolutely dazzled.
--
Adelaida Lower

INDIGNATION
Philip Roth, Houghton Mifflin, 2008, $26.00/C30, hb, 234pp, 9780547054841 / Jonathan Cape, 2008, £16.99, hb, 256pp, 9780224085137
    Up until the last thirty pages, this book reads like a wonderfully funny and bittersweet coming of age novel, though there are hints along the way that it is something more.  Marcus Messner, a young man from Newark, New Jersey, goes off to college in Winesburg, Ohio.  The love of his father, a kosher butcher, has become smothering.  Perhaps because it is 1950, with memories of World War II still fresh and the Korean War underway, the father sees the world as horribly dangerous.  He insists on keeping close tabs on his son and will not allow him to develop as an independent human being.  Therefore Marcus, who might otherwise have been content attending a local college, leaves home.  Entering a conservative, largely Protestant milieu, he suffers culture shock.  He clashes with the college’s dean of men, who insists he try to fit in more and not just study but have a social life.  In fact, Marcus is already in the midst of a romance.  A young woman has introduced him to sex and rocked his world.  Olivia, whose psychological demons have led her to attempt suicide, is clearly not the sort of girl his parents hoped he would meet at college.  Despite this, Roth leads us to believe that all will be well with Marcus, if the dean and his father just get off his back.  A diligent student who plans on a legal career, his future seems assured.  Then an unexpected chain of events intervenes.
    Philip Roth excels in breathing life into a time, place, and cast of characters.  In this moving work, among his best, he manages to encompass both comedy and gut-wrenching grief. --
Phyllis T.  Smith

WARRIOR OF ROME, PART ONE: Fire in the East
Harry Sidebottom, Michael Joseph, 2008, £12.99, hb, 414pp, 9780718153298
   
Fire in the East is part one of Dr Harry Sidebottom’s Warrior of Rome series and his first novel. He is a leading authority on ancient warfare, and the impressive appendix contains the historical details which are required reading in tandem with the unfolding story.
    In the third century AD, the Roman Empire is in turmoil as civil war tears Italy apart and emperor follows emperor in rapid succession. Out of the darkness comes a barbarian, Ballista, prince of his tribe and diplomatic hostage. Seventeen years pass and in 255 AD the Persian Sassanid Empire attacks Rome’s eastern territories, sweeping all before them. Ballista, now a citizen and sometime imperial favourite, is newly appointed to the post of Dux Ripae. In charge of the defences along the banks of the rivers Tigris and Euphrates and all the land between, he is empowered to hold this very edge of Empire.
    The novel is a master class in ancient warfare. Vast amounts of actual historical information are expended and one wonders how much is left for the remainder of the series. The story is skilfully constructed, harrowing at times with an imaginative scope. The clarity of observation of the minutiae of war and period detail reveals the author’s command of his subject. His characters, mostly male, are well defined and realistic and illuminate the different nationalities and passions prevalent in the empire at that time. Women play little part: the wife left behind and the feisty but tempting brigand’s daughter.
    This is a riveting book, the dominating feature being a city under siege. Dr Sidebottom generously acknowledges the debt owed to past historical novelists who have influenced him. The reader feels confident in the historical accuracy, but whether Warrior of Rome will become the mighty series that is envisaged remains in the gift of historical fiction fans. --
Gwen Sly

EARLY BRIGHT
Ami Silber, Toby, 2008, $24.95/C$24.95/£14.99, hb, 345pp, 9781592642410
    It’s a rare feat of literary prowess not only to create an unappealing character who is completely sympathetic, but also for a woman to write a believable man in the first person. Silber achieves both of these extraordinary results in Early Bright.
    In post-World War II Los Angeles, the anti-hero Louis Greenberg is a very talented jazz pianist who makes his living as a con artist, preying on the vulnerabilities of war widows and mothers who have lost their sons. Furthermore, he avoided going to war by stealing someone else’s 4-F papers, and as a result gained the censure of his father in New York—a fact that pursues him relentlessly as he tries to redeem himself through his music.
    As a Jew, Greenberg is an outsider—even more so because the music he plays is most at home in the black jazz clubs in a very segregated world. Yet he has friends and people who believe in him, not the least of whom is a beautiful black woman with whom he has a passionate relationship.
    Silber writes magnificently about music, about the feeling of performing jazz. She immerses us in the sordid, shallow world of the movie industry and reveals without sentiment and without cliché the racism that underlies life during this time. Most of all, the ultimate tragedy of Greenberg’s life hits the reader like a punch in the gut.

    Early Bright
beguiles with its mastery of language and drama and is highly recommended. -- Susanne Dunlap

EQUATOR
Miguel Sousa Tavares (trans. Peter Bush), Bloomsbury, 2008, £16.99, hb, 374pp, 9780747581741
    Luis Bernardo Valenca is a 37-year-old gentleman who owns a small shipping company. He lives a comfortable life, mixing with Lisbon’s high society and writing about politics in his spare time. However, his pampered and protected lifestyle is turned upside down when he is asked by King Dom Carlos to become governor of the tiny island of Sao Tome e Principe situated off the coast of equatorial West Africa. The English believe that slavery, although illegal, is still being practised on the island and are sending a diplomatic envoy to check out the situation.
    The storyline is one of conflict, both physical and mental. Tavares struggles to persuade the plantation owners and overseers to improve the working conditions of the Angolan labourers who are slaves in all but name. At the same time he must also deal with his own emotional and moral challenges, including his passionate love affair with the wife of the British envoy.
    Beautifully written, the descriptions of the island are vivid while the characters, with all their flaws and strengths, are strongly portrayed. This is an enjoyable read that will remain on my bookshelf to be read again. Recommended. --
Mike Ashworth

THE TOSS OF A LEMON
Padma Viswanathan, Harcourt, 2008, $26.00/£16.99, hb, 640pp, 9780151015337
    This phenomenal novel, set in India, follows the life of Sivakami from early childhood through old age, spanning the years 1896 through the 1950s. Following Brahmin tradition, Sivakami is married at age ten. When she is thirteen and comes of age, she is escorted to her husband’s home. By the time she is eighteen, she has given birth to two children and is widowed. The strictures for widowhood are incredibly stringent, but the remainder of Sivakami’s life is completely governed by them. Through this epic novel, we follow not only Sivakami’s life, but that of her two unusual children: Thangam, the daughter who sheds gold dust, and Vairum, a difficult young boy who becomes a financial success. The novel is rich in details about rituals of Brahmin life; it is also rich in its characterization of Sivakami’s many family members and near neighbors. Janaki, one of Thangam’s children, provides a point of focus, as does Muchami, who oversaw properties owned by Sivakami’s husband. He stays on to work for Sivakami and provides a view outside of her household, one denied to Sivakami herself.
    Critical events in Indian history during this time are reflected through the prism of the caste, although cracks begin to appear in the unanimity of reactions. It is Vairum who discards many of the traditions that his mother believes to be unquestionable, and who shifts the ground under her. While we recognize that Sivakami is extraordinarily conservative, such is our empathy for her that we want her view of the world protected.
    This novel was inspired by stories told by the author’s grandmother. Padma Viswanathan has transformed them into a captivating novel, one I wanted to continue long beyond its 600-plus pages. I recommend it most highly.
--
Trudi E. Jacobson

Veil of Lies
Jeri Westerson, Minotaur, 2008, $24.95, hb, 288pp, 9780312379773
    Poor Crispin Guest!  In Jeri Westerson’s debut novel, set in 14th-century London and described as “a medieval noir,” Crispin is slapped, backhanded, tied up and tossed in the Thames to drown, arrested, and slapped again.  The good news is Crispin is one of the most engaging characters I’ve come across in a long time.  A wealthy knight imprisoned for treason against Richard II, stripped of his title and possessions but spared with his life, Crispin now inhabits the gritty backstreets of London and abhors every minute of it.  To survive, he has set himself up as “The Tracker,” solving crimes for sixpence a day and expenses.  His latest investigation centers on his search for a missing relic which, in turn, leads to a series of murders involving “the Italians” and a beautiful young woman who is not quite what she seems.
    Westerson’s depiction of medieval London is honest, and Crispin’s loathing of it real.  For the most part heroic and steadfast, Crispin is also cynical and disillusioned, a man whose main focus is his hope that one day he will again live the comfortable life he once knew at court.  This, naturally, wreaks havoc in his romance with the woman he loves but who falls well below his former social status.
    To say Veil of Lies is a remarkable novel doesn’t do the book justice.  Just when the plot seems set on a fixed course, the author deftly arranges another neat surprise and keeps the pages turning.  The story is fresh, and engaging characters abound, with nary a medieval monk or nun in sight.  How can you not like a fellow who asks himself, “What am I now?  The Tracker.  What the hell is that?”  My only complaint is now I have to wait a year, probably, for the next title in the series. --
Alana White

Top of Page